Post-Modern MARVEL: Classical Super-heroes


by Ted Giese

Avengers: Age of Ultron is a sequel and in many ways does what many sequels today do: set up future films. It is also the current film in the MARVEL franchise and acts as a sort of crossroads where the pathways of many characters intersect. Walking into this super-hero movie unprepared would be confusing; without the help of Joss Whedon’s expert writing and direction, the film would be in danger of collapsing under its own weight.

The story begins with the Avengers (Captain America, Iron Man, Thor, The Incredible Hulk, Black Widow, and Hawkeye), a team of S.H.I.E.L.D. agents, and Tony Stark’s robots (Iron Legion drones) attacking an enemy base involved in human experimentation and other nefarious technology-based testing. Out of the base they retrieve the “business end” of a sceptre once belonging to Thor’s adopted brother Loki. It’s a powerful piece of alien technology which had fallen into the hands of the wicked organization Hydra first introduced in Captain America: The First Avenger.

Before Thor leaves to return to his homeland, Asgard, with the remains of his villainous brother’s sceptre, Iron Man/Tony Stark asks to have a couple of days to study it. He and Dr. Bruce Banner/The Incredible Hulk use it to help build an artificial intelligence (AI) named Ultron. The AI was envisioned to be a protector of the Earth against the kind of intergalactic invaders the Avengers faced in Avengers Assemble. As Stark puts it, “I tried to create a suit of armour around the world… but I created something terrible.”

Avengers-Age-of-Ultron-PosterThe new AI Ultron becomes a threat to the very humanity he was envisioned to protect. In his first moments of “life.” he is greeted by Tony Stark’s AI butler/lab assistant J.A.R.V.I.S., and proceeds to “murder” him and take control of Stark’s Iron Legion drones. In Ultron’s initial development he learns everything he knows from the internet and, based on what he finds there, judges the Avengers and humanity unworthy of living on earth. When asked why he wants to wipe out humanity, he simply says, “Noah.”

It seems Ultron has read the Bible online and drawn from it a sort of misguided inspiration. The self-deluded AI thinks of himself as a kind of god, yet he is also jealous of humanity and desires to have a body that is not just robotic but biological. He also wants to be free from humanity and Tony Stark, often quoting lyrics from the Disney film Pinocchio, “I’ve got no strings to hold me down to make me fret, or make me frown. I had strings, but now I’m free. There are no strings on me!” Unlike Pinocchio, who becomes a good little boy in the end, Ultron without strings is thoroughly villainous, an unrestrained merciless menace who doesn’t find redemption.

Unlike Pinocchio, who becomes a good little boy in the end, Ultron without strings is thoroughly villainous.

Avengers: The Age of Ultron is so full of details and subplots it would be a challenge to see the bigger story if the director Joss Whedon had not provided some obvious hints along the way. Near the film’s beginning, inside one of the jet planes in which the Avengers travel, a bumper sticker is plastered on the cockpit wall that reads, “Jarvis Is My Co-Pilot.” This tongue-in-cheek reference to the bumper sticker “Jesus Is My Co-Pilot,” turns out to be less humorous and more serious when J.A.R.V.I.S. reemerges as a saviour character in the film’s third act.

Earlier, when the maniacal Ultron obtains some “vibranium,” the substance from which Captain America’s shield is made, he ironically proclaims the words of Matthew 16:18, “On this rock, I will build my church.” And why does he say that about the vibranium? Ultron planned to use it to fashion a hybrid alloyed/biological body for himself, a body he believed would all-powerful and virtually indestructible. This is an ironic statement because this indestructible body becomes the instrument of Ultron’s downfall when the Avengers thwart his plan and the remnants of J.A.R.V.I.S. are uploaded into a newly-fashioned AI hybrid vibranium body.

A Savior Story?

This new AI isn’t just J.A.R.V.I.S. version 2.0; something unexpected happens and the new J.A.R.V.I.S. refers to himself as, “I am, I am.” Later, this AI is referred to as The Vision. With the AI calling itself “I am,” Whedon undoubtedly intending to call to mind the name God gave for Himself at the burning bush. There God had said to Moses, “I AM WHO I AM.” The Vision, who acts as a kind of virtually-indestructible, god-like AI then becomes the foil for Ultron. It’s as though J.A.R.V.I.S. is resurrected from the dead and in his resurrected body fights Ultron as a servant for humanity. Where Ultron wanted no strings, The Vision gladly takes on those strings becoming what Ultron calls a “slave” in service to the needs of humanity. In essence, The Vision becomes what Stark had hoped for.

Ultron: The world needed a shield… Stark settled for a slave.

The Vision: Human beings are fearful and in need of protection. But then, that fear can inspire them to do great things.

Ultron: You’re unbelievably naïve.

The Vision: Well, I was born yesterday.

On the surface these Scriptural references will seem like Christian content worthy of some praise. However, they deserve some second thought. Whedon uses Scripture as a sort of short hand to economically transmit larger concepts to the audience. This is not so much faithful Christian content as it is a director using Scripture to achieve his own narrative ends. Also note that most of the Scriptural quotations and theological remarks are made by Ultron who is clearly the film’s villain. At one point while sitting in a church, Ultron says,” [They] put the building in the middle of the city so that everyone could be equally close to God. I like that, the symmetry, the geometry of belief.” And where does Ultron sit? On a throne in the middle of that church.

Whedon uses Scripture as a sort of short hand to economically transmit larger concepts to the audience. This is not so much faithful Christian content as it is a director using Scripture to achieve his own narrative ends.

For Whedon, Avengers: Age of Ultron comes across as something more like Greek mythology with Christian window dressing. But what about the Scriptural theme of redemption? Yes, this is a film filled with themes of redemption, but generally speaking much of that is self-redemption. As Captain America says, “This isn’t about beating Ultron; it’s about proving we’re not monsters.” Ultron, the film’s true monster, is depicted like a Titan, a kind of malevolent Greek mythological god.

Of course, The Vision and Ultron are not the only “god”-like characters in the film. In fact, alongside Thor, who is based on the Thor of Norse mythology, some of the other Avengers are also spoken of in the same terms. Hawkeye (who turns in one of the film’s great performances) in a conversation with his wife concerning his involvement with the Avengers says, “You don’t think they need me?” to which she replies, “Actually, I think they do. They’re gods, and they need someone to keep them down to Earth.” This idea of them being like gods/heroes from a pagan pantheon is reinforced in the film’s credits which depict them in sculpted marble vanquishing evil Ultron—a contemporary twist on classical Greek sculpture.

What are Christians to make of Avengers: Age of Ultron? Whedon’s film is a soap-opera writ large, an epic investigation of chaos vs. control at the intersection of ego and responsibility. But it isn’t a Christian film—nor was it expected to be. In fact, the plethora of Scriptural quotes and Christian references may come as a surprise to many viewers. In the end it is an entertaining, carefully crafted story complete with wise cracks and even an unlikely Avengers romance (between Black Widow and the Hulk). The film does its job advancing the big picture, meta-narrative of the MARVEL “industrial complex,” and it will also do its job of making a marvelous amount of money.

As for the spiritual dimension of the film, what Whedon delivers is more clever and efficient style than enduring, deep substance. It may taste sweet, but like cotton candy, it will dissolve quickly when eaten.


Rev. Ted Giese is associate pastor of Mount Olive Lutheran Church (Regina, Saskatchewan). He is a contributor to Reformation Rush Hour on KFUO AM Radio, The Canadian Lutheran, and the LCMS Reporter, as well as movie reviewer for the “Issues, Etc.” radio program.  Follow him on Twitter @RevTedGiese.

One response to “Post-Modern MARVEL: Classical Super-heroes”

  1. […] as a sequel to Captain America: The Winter Soldier, it picks up following the concluding events of Avengers: Age of Ultron. In that film, the battle of Sokovia saved humanity from the artificial intelligence Ultron […]

Leave a Reply

Posted By: Matthew Block
Posted On: June 9, 2015
Posted In: Feature Stories, Headline, Movie Review,

More Resources